- Research By Topic
- Student Programs
- Executive Programs
- GSB Social Innovators
- Community Engagement
- About CSI
Skip to Content
Change lives. Change organizations. Change the world.
When a company breaks the law, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) would really rather it just say so. And many of them actually do. Under the EPA’s Audit Policy, violators who voluntarily report themselves can get certain penalties reduced or waived if they commit to ongoing self-regulation. The companies set up internal compliance procedures and promise never to do it again.
“These firms have agreed to do something above and beyond what’s required by law,” says Jodi Short, an associate law professor at Georgetown University. But is that promise any more than window dressing? Short found that when firms commit to policing themselves, they do in fact have better compliance outcomes—under certain conditions. “There are things regulators can do to promote the meaningful implementation of self-regulatory commitments,” she says. In particular, watching them is more effective than warning them.
Looking at hundreds of industrial facilities subject to the Clean Air Act across the United States between 1993 and 2003, Short